Page 1 of 1
GM's value
Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 9:42 am
by goikiri
Hi guys,
I had an idea. I want all of GMs assess to other GMs in the league. I can create 10 different themes and any GM can punctuate from 0 to 10 and explain our reply with words)
Themes:
-Draft selection (if GM hit/fault in our selections)
-Trades (if GM hit/fault in our selections)
-Writes in our forum (active/passive writing in our forum)
-Knowledge (know/ignore about DDSPB3)
-Roster management (balanced/unbalanced roster)
-Philosophy and set offense use (
-Players development (develop/impoverish players)
-Financial control (have cap/on hard cap)
-Meeting or excideed targets (excideed/lack targets)
-Active making/answering offers (make-answer/ignore offers)
Agree?
Re: GM's value
Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 12:22 pm
by goikiri
For example :
Dennis by goikiri
goikiri wrote:
-Draft selection 7 No big decisions because he hadn't high picks. Tyler Ennis was good pick.
-Trades 8 Without failures except Carmelo's add IMO
-Writes in our forum 9 Awesome work with draft. Great.
-Knowledge (know/ignore about DDSPB3) 10 He was administrator. He dominates perfect the game.
-Roster management 8 Always play with balanced roster.
-Philosophy and set offense use 8 Use many changes in each sim for win each game.
-Players development 8 He develops Chroeder, Bullock or Wear very well. Nit fails here.
-Financial control 6 He always have a players with big contracts. Bad for the cap.
-Meeting or excideed targets 6 Since second season, he was favourite but he has never play the Finals.
-Active making/answering offers 9 Tireless. Send fair offers.
Total : 79
Re: GM's value
Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 12:38 pm
by Mattybriand
goikiri wrote:For example :
Dennis by goikiri
goikiri wrote:
-Draft selection 7 No big decisions because he hadn't high picks. Tyler Ennis was good pick.
-Trades 8 Without failures except Carmelo's add IMO
-Writes in our forum 9 Awesome work with draft. Great.
-Knowledge (know/ignore about DDSPB3) 10 He was administrator. He dominates perfect the game.
-Roster management 8 Always play with balanced roster.
-Philosophy and set offense use 8 Use many changes in each sim for win each game.
-Players development 8 He develops Chroeder, Bullock or Wear very well. Nit fails here.
-Financial control 6 He always have a players with big contracts. Bad for the cap.
-Meeting or excideed targets 6 Since second season, he was favourite but he has never play the Finals.
-Active making/answering offers 9 Tireless. Send fair offers.
Total : 79
Tbh I think that's a lot of research not sure I'd be able to have the time for all of that
Re: GM's value
Posted: Thu May 05, 2016 12:44 pm
by goikiri
Mattybriand wrote:goikiri wrote:For example :
Dennis by goikiri
goikiri wrote:
-Draft selection 7 No big decisions because he hadn't high picks. Tyler Ennis was good pick.
-Trades 8 Without failures except Carmelo's add IMO
-Writes in our forum 9 Awesome work with draft. Great.
-Knowledge (know/ignore about DDSPB3) 10 He was administrator. He dominates perfect the game.
-Roster management 8 Always play with balanced roster.
-Philosophy and set offense use 8 Use many changes in each sim for win each game.
-Players development 8 He develops Chroeder, Bullock or Wear very well. Nit fails here.
-Financial control 6 He always have a players with big contracts. Bad for the cap.
-Meeting or excideed targets 6 Since second season, he was favourite but he has never play the Finals.
-Active making/answering offers 9 Tireless. Send fair offers.
Total : 79
Tbh I think that's a lot of research not sure I'd be able to have the time for all of that
Very easy for you :
Goikiri by Matty
0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0 total 0 reason : PG13 trade
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 10:18 am
by 8timechamp
This could be real interesting if gm's put some time into it and answered the questions. Would show what gm's think of how other gm's are managing their team.
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 11:35 am
by OneNole
Its an interesting idea but would never work as not enough would do it and too many would give biased reviews instead of their true opinion.
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 11:39 am
by 8timechamp
OneNole wrote:Its an interesting idea but would never work as not enough would do it and too many would give biased reviews instead of their true opinion.
i guess that's true. People dont want to hurt other peoples feelings.
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 11:40 am
by OneNole
8timechamp wrote:OneNole wrote:Its an interesting idea but would never work as not enough would do it and too many would give biased reviews instead of their true opinion.
i guess that's true. People dont want to hurt other peoples feelings.
Lol, no, the other way around.
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 11:42 am
by 8timechamp
OneNole wrote:8timechamp wrote:OneNole wrote:Its an interesting idea but would never work as not enough would do it and too many would give biased reviews instead of their true opinion.
i guess that's true. People dont want to hurt other peoples feelings.
Lol, no, the other way around.
haha
I'm willing to give honest review's if more gm's are up to it.
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 11:43 am
by Dennis
OneNole wrote:8timechamp wrote:OneNole wrote:Its an interesting idea but would never work as not enough would do it and too many would give biased reviews instead of their true opinion.
i guess that's true. People dont want to hurt other peoples feelings.
Lol, no, the other way around.
My vote for Brett: 1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1, -10
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 11:51 am
by lakeshowak7
I'd give everyone 10's. Participation trophies for everyone.
Re: GM's value
Posted: Fri May 06, 2016 12:18 pm
by emplep7
goikiri wrote:Mattybriand wrote:
Tbh I think that's a lot of research not sure I'd be able to have the time for all of that
Very easy for you :
Goikiri by Matty
0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0 total 0 reason : PG13 trade
Haha. That gave me a good laugh.