Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
- KW
- CSL Champ 2017
- Posts: 10688
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 5:18 am
- Location: CO
- Contact:
Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I'm thinking about organizing a project similar to the annual NBA Rank that ESPN and SI run most years, and the CSL Top 100 one that (correct me if I'm wrong) Marcos and Myles did years ago.
There's a few different ways I'd think about running it:
1) A team rates the players (on a scale of 0 to 10) in their division and we average the ratings to get a player score.
2) Each team rates the players in another division (eliminates potential bias but less familiarity with the players they're rating)
3) Each team rates players of a particular position
4) A group of a GMs rates all players
In any of the first 3, we'd whittle the list down to the top ~150 and then get a smaller group of GMs to rate them to find the top 100.
Let me know if this project is of interest, and in what capacity you'd be willing to participate! Ideally, all 30 teams could participate and rate 75-90 players each but I'm not going to force anybody to do anything. As long as each player has 3 data points I can average together, I feel comfortable this project will be fun and valuable for the league.
There's a few different ways I'd think about running it:
1) A team rates the players (on a scale of 0 to 10) in their division and we average the ratings to get a player score.
2) Each team rates the players in another division (eliminates potential bias but less familiarity with the players they're rating)
3) Each team rates players of a particular position
4) A group of a GMs rates all players
In any of the first 3, we'd whittle the list down to the top ~150 and then get a smaller group of GMs to rate them to find the top 100.
Let me know if this project is of interest, and in what capacity you'd be willing to participate! Ideally, all 30 teams could participate and rate 75-90 players each but I'm not going to force anybody to do anything. As long as each player has 3 data points I can average together, I feel comfortable this project will be fun and valuable for the league.
- Stockton12
- Chairman of the Board
- Posts: 3296
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 9:38 pm
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
i like the idea but not every gm is active ( cough ) so you might not get everyone to vote
maybe select the top 5 players from each team then go from there?
maybe select the top 5 players from each team then go from there?
-
- Chairman of the Board
- Posts: 4661
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 5:55 am
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I honestly feel like this is a lot of work that people won't have time for. We have trouble getting people to participate in much less time-intensive things.
- andrei
- Chairman of the Board
- Posts: 6779
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 8:26 am
- Location: Dublin, Ireland
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I think if the idea is to come up with a top 100 then ranking all 450 players is somewhat excessive.
Top 100 is what 3 players per team on average - so if somebody like KW could do a sanity check on how many players have a legit chance of making top 100, we could narrow it down significantly. Maybe no more than 5 players per team. Now you can rank 20 players per division instead of 75.
I look at Grizz and there maybe 2 - Culver/Bruno - that are legit candidates and a third one in Varnado who maybe has a chance. But no need to bother with the rest.
Top 100 is what 3 players per team on average - so if somebody like KW could do a sanity check on how many players have a legit chance of making top 100, we could narrow it down significantly. Maybe no more than 5 players per team. Now you can rank 20 players per division instead of 75.
I look at Grizz and there maybe 2 - Culver/Bruno - that are legit candidates and a third one in Varnado who maybe has a chance. But no need to bother with the rest.
Congrats to season 16 ASL champion SoulKey. For the Swarm!
- cb4raptorscb4
- Commissioner
- Posts: 2363
- Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2019 8:19 pm
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
A handful of GMs is probably easiest. In any case though, I'd be down to help.
Golden State Warriors
Kris Dunn | PJ Dozier | Ding Yanyuhang | Kevon Looney | Chimezie Metu
Devonte Graham | Nimrod Levi | Tariq Owens | Johnny Hamilton
'23: 34-48 (5-8 as GM)
'24: 40-42, 1st Round Exit
'25: 50-32, Championship Round Loss (4-3)
'26: 48-34, 1st Round Exit
'27: 44-38, Missed Playoffs
'28: 39-43, 1st Round Exit
'29: 57-25, Championship Round Loss (4-2)
'30: 48-34, Conference Finals Loss (4-1)
Kris Dunn | PJ Dozier | Ding Yanyuhang | Kevon Looney | Chimezie Metu
Devonte Graham | Nimrod Levi | Tariq Owens | Johnny Hamilton
'23: 34-48 (5-8 as GM)
'24: 40-42, 1st Round Exit
'25: 50-32, Championship Round Loss (4-3)
'26: 48-34, 1st Round Exit
'27: 44-38, Missed Playoffs
'28: 39-43, 1st Round Exit
'29: 57-25, Championship Round Loss (4-2)
'30: 48-34, Conference Finals Loss (4-1)
- emplep7
- Commissioner & CSL Champ 2018
- Posts: 6694
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 5:06 pm
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I agree that it will probably be hard to get everyone to rank players, but if a good handful of GMs are free to help I think thats the best way to go.
I could probably help a bit, but with the off-season coming up it might be bad timing. Let me know though.
I could probably help a bit, but with the off-season coming up it might be bad timing. Let me know though.
- TheTwoWallaces
- CEO
- Posts: 2049
- Joined: Thu May 23, 2019 4:31 pm
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I'm down to rank some imaginary humans
DETROIT BASKETBALL
Krejci | Melton | Campazzo
Porter | Notice | King
Johnson | Kispert
McDaniels | Martin | Petrusev
Wiseman | Stewart
Krejci | Melton | Campazzo
Porter | Notice | King
Johnson | Kispert
McDaniels | Martin | Petrusev
Wiseman | Stewart
- KW
- CSL Champ 2017
- Posts: 10688
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 5:18 am
- Location: CO
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
Pretty fair point about the lower tier of players not necessarily needing to be ranked to create a top 100. The original list of players can be cut down substantially to 150-200, with about 4-8 representatives from each team.
- mgtr81
- Chairman of the Board
- Posts: 3623
- Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 6:14 am
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I like the idea, but honestly, I won't have the required time to participate. I'm sorry. Good luck with this project.
- Ocons
- Chairman of the Board
- Posts: 3094
- Joined: Wed Jul 15, 2015 4:33 pm
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
Same and no surprise I'm sure. Love the idea but there's no chance I'm going to get a ranking list over to anyone in any decent amount of time. That, and I have no idea who half the league is so my ratings won't matter much.
Hopefully you can figure it out because it would certainly be cool to see.
Hopefully you can figure it out because it would certainly be cool to see.
Clown.Show.League
- bt
- CSL Champ 2020, 2023 & 2027
- Posts: 5815
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 6:12 am
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
Cool idea and what Andrei said is spot on.
Anyway, I'm down to help/vote plus I feel like a range of responses would help iron out the averages a little as we all have our own opinions.
Anyway, I'm down to help/vote plus I feel like a range of responses would help iron out the averages a little as we all have our own opinions.
sacramento kings
tremont waters | skylar mays | nigel johnson
matisse thybulle | justin james
robert franks | darius bazely | john butler
donta hall | xavier tillman | patrick williams
jon collins | jonathan isaac | norvel pelle | mfiondu kabengele
CSL CHAMPION 2020, 2023, 2027
tremont waters | skylar mays | nigel johnson
matisse thybulle | justin james
robert franks | darius bazely | john butler
donta hall | xavier tillman | patrick williams
jon collins | jonathan isaac | norvel pelle | mfiondu kabengele
CSL CHAMPION 2020, 2023, 2027
- Flaming Homer
- Commissioner
- Posts: 5762
- Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2018 6:31 pm
- Contact:
Re: Gauging interest: CSL Rank Offseason 2027
I'm in as well
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests